Skip to content

Toxic Controlling Relationships Aren’t Loving

Make No Mistake – Toxic Controlling Relationships Aren’t Loving

Healthy relationships don’t smother and dominate the other person. Loving relationships are about looking out for the other person. Controlling others is like putting them in chains to restrict their movements.

In an excerpt from Dr Tim Clinton’s book, ‘Break Through, When to Give In, How to Push Back’ we can learn how these often toxic and controlling relationships are not loving, but instead are a sad and twisted misinterpretation.

10 Signs of an Unhealthy Relationship

“I’d die without you.”
“You make me whole.”
“Without you, I’d be hopelessly lost.”
“You define me.”

These phrases may sound charming, but this kind of “love” can actually be very destructive. In the name of “love,” it’s easy to put up with all kinds of craziness. To make excuses. To ignore reality.

When we define love as dominance, we feel completely justified in smothering people with too much attention and direction. And when we define love as compliance, we feel so utterly incompetent that we’re happy to let an assertive person tell us how to live. However, such misguided devotion doesn’t truly satisfy us. It robs us of sanity, peace, joy and the true love of a healthy relationship.

So how do you know? Here are a few signs that you may be in an unhealthy, enmeshed relationship. Do you…

  1. Close your eyes to irresponsible behaviour?
  2. Keep secrets or tolerate abuse?
  3. Sacrifice to cover up someone else’s mistakes?
  4. Cater to a lazy person’s whims?
  5. Caving into an angry person’s demands?
  6. Make excuses?
  7. Justify bad behaviour?
  8. Accept the blame for something you never did?
  9. Enable an addiction?
  10. Lie to yourself or others?

If you answered “yes” to many of these statements, it’s likely that you may be stuck in an enmeshed relationship. These relationships leave a legacy of heartbreak and manipulation. But that legacy can be changed if we are willing to open our eyes and take an honest look at ourselves and our relationships.

Often, in the name of love, we bail out people who won’t help themselves. Each time we insist, “This is the last time!”

In the name of love, we endure name-calling, the silent treatment, temper tantrums, even violence. We try to assure ourselves, “Deep down he’s a good person with a kind heart…he’ll change.” But he never really does. In the name of love, we cower in the face of an angry person’s demands and settle for whatever peace we can get, which isn’t much.

Why? What keeps us there? A misunderstanding of love.

What the world calls “love” often isn’t true love at all. If our version of love is destroying us and someone we care about, and then let’s not call it love. There are lots of other names for it, but it’s not love.

We may call it love, but enmeshment is:

  • Smothering a weak, needy person with too much attention and direction
  • Giving in (meekly or defiantly) to the demands of a dominating person
  • Taking responsibility for another’s choices instead of letting him experience the consequences of his decisions
  • Losing your identity in someone else, being dominated by them, and taking on that person’s emotions, values, thoughts and behaviours
  • Switching roles with your children and expecting them to meet your emotional needs
  • Building your relationship on power instead of mutual respect

If you’ve been mistaking counterfeit love for the real thing, then you need a breakthrough—a flash of insight and a dose of courage to take action and change the status quo. A weak, misguided definition of love causes us to give in repeatedly, but a stronger, more accurate view of love directs us to speak and act wisely to address evil, manipulative behaviour…”

God’s Version of love is found in 1 Corinthians 13:4-7

“Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. 5 It does not dishonour others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. 6 Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. 7 It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, and always perseveres.”

Sources:

Permission Attained – Dr Tim Clinton – http://www.timclinton.com

 

Share this:
Where to get help

24/7 Helplines
Lifeline: 13 11 14
Kids Helplines: 1800 551 800
Mensline: 1300 789 978
Beyond Blue: 1300 22 46 36
Headspace: 1800 650 890

Visit Abound to find a Christian Counsellor suited to your needs.

Related posts

A road under construction at sunrise, or a wide open highway through Australian landscape with warm light and a sense of invitation.

Build the Highway: Preparing Pathways for People to Return to God

June 11, 2026 | Counselling, Faith

Build the Highway: Preparing Pathways for People to Return to God There is a kind of need that is hard to ignore. We see it in the exhaustion of leaders, the anxiety of young people, the grief sitting quietly beneath the surface of families, the loneliness in our communities, and the spiritual confusion many people…

Read more
Aerial view of intersecting pathways across green fields, symbolising a mid-year pause, reflection and choosing the way forward.

2026 Is Approaching Half Time: Making the Second Half Count

May 27, 2026 | Faith, Featured Blog

Making the Second Half Count Ancient Paths, Deep Flourishing, and the Life-Giving Way Forward It’s almost half way through 2026—how did that happen? The year that once stretched out before us with possibility is already approaching its midpoint. For some, the first half of the year has brought momentum, clarity and growth. For others, it…

Read more
Abstract interwoven white geometric pattern representing complexity and Christian counselling formation

Faith, Psychology, and Formation in Christian Counselling

February 6, 2026 | Counselling, Faith

Learning to Hold It Together: Why Formation Matters in Christian Counselling Christian counselling is never just about learning techniques. It is about becoming a particular kind of person — one who can listen deeply, reflect wisely, and respond faithfully in the complexity of human lives. This commitment to Christian counselling formation recognises that who we…

Read more
An open interior door with light visible beyond.

Spiritual Formation, Fear, and Following God’s Call

January 24, 2026 | Faith

Ready to Change? Most people do not resist change because they are stubborn or unwilling. They resist because change asks something of them — emotionally, spiritually, and relationally. Often, the desire for change is present long before action follows. People recognise patterns that are no longer life-giving. They notice recurring struggles, emotional reactions, or relational…

Read more